Nominations: Tuesday, 26 January 1858, Polling: Friday, 5 February 1858
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Egan, Daniel (Re-elected)
196
68.29
Hebden, George
91
31.71
Formal Votes
287
Informal Votes
0
0.00
Total Votes / Turnout
287
60.81
Source: SMH 3 March 1858, p.5 col.4. Note that Egan had reported a much better result for himself published in the SMH 16 February, p.8 col.1. Goulburn Herald also published a 203-95 result, 20 February, p.2 col.4.