| Related Orders, Precedents and Rulings |
|---|
| 2013 Precedent | 1. During a member speaking in reply in a debate on a general notice of motion being given precedence, a member moved that the member be not further heard. The question was negatived on division. PD 27/2/2013, 18121; VP 27/2/2013, 1451-1452 |
| 2011 Precedent | 1. During a Minister's answer to a question, the question was put 'That the member be not further heard', which was negatived on division. Upon which, standing and sessional orders were suspended to extend the Minister's speaking time by an additional five minutes. PD 9/08/2011, 3987-8; VP 9/08/2011, 263-4 |
| S.O. 66 of 1994 (Repealed) | 66. A Member may move without notice that a Member who is speaking "That the Honourable Member for ..... be not further heard". The question shall be decided without debate or amendment. |
| 2004 Precedent | During a Minister's reply to a motion for urgent consideration a member moved that the Minister be not further heard, which was negatived on division. VP 08/12/2004, p 1192 |
| 2003 Precedent | 1. When a motion was moved to suspend standing and sessional orders the Leader of the Opposition argued that the Opposition had been denied an opportunity to read into Hansard a statutory declaration. The Speaker warned the Leader of the Opposition that he would be grossly out of order if he proceeded to read the statutory declaration into Hansard during the course of the debate. The Leader of the Opposition attempted to read the statutory declaration but was prevented from doing so when a majority of the House agreed that the Leader of the Opposition should be not further heard. PD 18/11/2003, 5134 - 35 |
| 2000 Precedent | 1. During debate on a motion to suspend standing and sessional orders to permit the tabling and incorporation in Hansard of a letter from the Member of Ku-ring-gai to the Premier of Victoria, a Member moved 'That the Member for Ku-ring-gai be not further heard'. Motion agreed to on division. VP 25/05/00, 502 2. During debate on a motion to suspend Standing and Sessional Orders in relation to the routine of business a Member moved 'That the Member for Gosford be not further heard'. Motion agreed to on division. VP 25/05/.00, 504 3. During debate on a motion for urgent consideration a Member moved 'That the Member for Wyong be not further heard'. Motion negatived on division. VP 20/06/00, 602 4. During debate on a motion on rural and regional families a Member moved 'That the Member for Murray - Darling be not further heard'. Motion negatived on division. VP 22/06/00, 628 5. During a ministerial statement on truth in trading laws a Member moved 'That the Minister for Fair Trading and Minister for Sport and Recreation be not further heard'. Motion negatived on division. VP 22/06/00, 636 6. During questions without notice a Member moved 'That the Premier be not further heard'. Motion negatived on division. VP 10/08/00 7. During a motion to suspend standing and sessional orders a Member moved, 'That the Member for Gosford be not further heard'. Motion agreed to, on division
VP 16/08/00, 732 8. During a motion to suspend standing and sessional orders a Member moved, 'That the Member for Lane Cove be not further heard'. Motion agreed to, on division. VP 16/08/00, 742 9. During debate on a motion on the Crimes (Forensic Procedures) Legislation a Member moved, 'That the Member for Newcastle be not further heard'. Motion negatived on division. VP 16/11/00, 887 |
| 1999 Precedent | 1. Member rose on a matter of privilege. Another member moved, That the Member for Ku-ring-gai be not further heard which was agreed to on division. VP 29/06/99, 196 2. During debate on a motion to suspend standing orders in relation to bills which originated in the Legislative Council member moved, That the Member for Gosford be not further heard. Motion agreed to on division. VP 29/06/99, 197-198; VP 29/06/99, 207-208 |
| 1997 Precedent | 1. That the Premier be not further heard, negatived on division. VP 06/05/97, 828 2. During Question Time, Leader of the Opposition moved, That the Minister, be not further heard. Negatived on division. VP 24/09/97, 68 2. Member moved, That the Minister for Fair Trading and Minister for Women be not further heard. Negatived on division. VP 15/10/97, 134 |
| 1996 Precedent | 1. Moved and negatived on division. VP 20/11/96, 628-629; VP 27/11/96, 684 |
| 1995 Precedent | 1. Motion moved - negatived on division. VP 24/5/95, 53 2. Motion moved - negatived on casting vote of Speaker. VP 1/6/95, 109-110 3. Motion moved on motion of dissent against Speaker’s ruling. Speaker gave casting vote with the "Noes" - "to ensure that freedom of speech in this House is not infringed". PD 1/6/95, 596 4. Motion moved during Question Time. Carried on division on casting vote of Speaker. VP 23/11/95, 441-442. Again moved and carried on division 442-443. |
| 1991 Precedent | 1. Motion moved and agreed to. VP 4/12/91, 410 |